AI Isn’t the End of Customer Service—It’s the Beginning of Something Smarter
Why the future of support belongs to humans who guide machines—not those who clean up after them.
ONE WEEK UNTIL The Psychology of CX 101 is available
Launching September 16
101 Psychology- Backed Plays To Reduce Churn, Increase Trust, and Prove ROI
Last week, I shared a big idea:
AI will soon handle most customer service tasks. Humans will still matter, but only in the places where machines can’t replace us.
This week, let’s go a step further.
If AI is doing most of the work, and humans are the differentiator, then the real question is: how do the two actually work together?
I call the answer the Human-as-Guide model.
Instead of waiting for AI to fail and then stepping in, this changes the play. People aren’t just backups. They’re guides: coaching, correcting, and steering AI in real time.
And here’s the good news: we’re already seeing this work in leading companies.
Why the Old Model Keeps Failing (and Costing Millions)
The old approach, “human-in-the-loop”, looked good on paper: let AI handle the basics, then pull in a human when things got tricky.
But here’s what actually happens:
Customers get stuck in endless bot loops.
Agents parachute into chaotic conversations with zero context.
Companies pay the price in money and reputation.
Some painful examples:
Zillow’s iBuying experiment lost $881M, shutting down the division and cutting 25% of staff.
Knight Capital: A trading glitch cost $440M in 30 minutes, nearly bankrupting the firm.
Air Canada: Ordered to refund a bereavement fare after its chatbot gave misleading advice.
Some are extreme, but the lesson is the same: left unsupervised, AI breaks faster and costs more than we’re ready for.
Bottom line: Humans can’t just be last-resort safety nets. They need to be built into the system from the start.
What Human-as-Guide Actually Means
In this model, humans move from rescue operators to supervisors and coaches:
Watching AI’s performance in real time.
Tweaking decisions on the fly.
Teaching nuance as it unfolds.
Stepping in when empathy, judgment, or compliance demand it.
And it works. A Harvard Business School study found that agents supported with real-time AI suggestions respond 20% faster and with greater empathy. That combination builds loyalty and drives profitability.
Imagine This
You’re running CX at a fast-growing fintech. Your AI system handles 80% of inbound chats. Huge cost savings.
Then a VIP flags potential fraud. The bot misinterprets, loops them back to FAQs, and the customer storms off. A few tweets later, you’re trending for all the wrong reasons.
The AI didn’t fail. The oversight did.
Who was supervising for edge cases?
Who trained the AI to recognize urgency?
Without a human-as-guide, cracks quickly turn into headlines.
Why It Works (When Done Right)
Companies embracing this approach are already seeing wins:
30% faster resolutions: AI handles volume, humans handle nuance.
Trust rises: customers know someone’s watching.
Mistakes get caught early: before they go viral.
AI improves in real time, thanks to agent interventions.
Some proof points:
Lumen Technologies: Saved $50M/year letting AI tackle low-complexity sales tasks.
Microsoft: Reportedly cut $500M in call center costs with smart automation.
Air India: AI now handles 97% of queries, freeing humans for high-stakes cases.
Notice the pattern: Humans weren’t less present. They were more.
When They’re Not
The flip side is ugly.
Some companies hide armies of human agents behind an “AI-powered” label. This practice now has a nickname: AI agent washing.
Customers notice. A Gartner survey found 64% of customers prefer brands without AI in service. Not because they hate tech, but because they’ve experienced its mishandling.
The money costs are real. The trust costs may be even bigger.
Why More Companies Haven’t Shifted
This isn’t really a tech issue. It’s cultural and structural:
Agents aren’t trained to coach AI.
Feedback isn’t rewarded, only resolution numbers.
Many workers see AI as a threat, not a teammate.
Leaders still treat oversight as optional.
But oversight isn’t a luxury. It’s insurance.
Just ask Lloyd’s of London. They are now offering insurance against chatbot errors. Regulators in finance and healthcare are already hinting at oversight requirements.
Where It’s Heading
Over the next two years, Human-as-Guide is likely to become standard practice for customer-facing AI.
But CX leaders shouldn’t wait for mandates.
The path forward is already clear, and it begins with three shifts that redefine how teams work with AI.
First, redefine roles.
Customer service agents can’t be seen as case closers anymore. Their new value lies in acting as AI supervisors—balancing technical know-how with the empathy that customers demand.
Research from Harvard’s Shunyuan Zhang and Das Narayandas shows that when chatbots assist rather than replace agents, the results are striking: humans respond not just faster, but with greater empathy.
Second, rethink training.
Scripts and handle-time metrics are relics of the old world. What teams need now is training that equips them to spot bias, correct AI errors in real time, and know when to override the system altogether.
Companies like Salesforce and Help Scout are reframing their programs to emphasize this supervisory role, preparing agents to guide AI rather than just coexist with it.
Third, build better handoffs.
Customers should never feel like they’re starting from scratch when moving from bot to human.
Clean escalation paths, seamless data transfer, and full transparency keep trust intact. Without this, organizations risk creating escalation loops—bouncing customers between machines and humans without ever resolving the issue.
These steps won’t just improve service quality.
They will create new roles—“AI supervisors” and “AI coaches”—blending technical fluency with emotional intelligence. Metrics will evolve to measure the quality of supervision rather than raw speed.
And most importantly, trust will become the differentiator: companies that master human-AI collaboration will scale faster, reduce risk, and inspire greater loyalty than those chasing automation at all costs.
Takeaway
The future of customer service isn’t machines replacing people. It’s about repositioning humans as guides, supervisors, and coaches.
This isn’t sci-fi. It’s already working.
Companies that embrace this model don’t just avoid million-dollar errors or lawsuits. They build trust, scale smarter, and deliver service customers actually remember for the right reasons.
So ask yourself:
👉 Where in your support flow are humans still rescuing AI?
👉 And what would it look like if they were leading instead?
What Successful CX Leaders Do on Sundays
DCX Links: Six must-read picks to fuel your leadership journey delivered every Sunday morning. Dive into the latest edition now!
👋 Please Reach Out
I created this newsletter to help customer-obsessed pros like you deliver exceptional experiences and tackle challenges head-on. But honestly? The best part is connecting with awesome, like-minded people—just like you! 😊
Here’s how you can get involved:
Got feedback? Tell me what’s working, what’s not, or what you’d love to see next.
Stuck on something? Whether it’s a CX challenge, strategy question, or team issue, hit me up—I’m here to help.
Just want to say hi? Seriously, don’t be shy. I’d love to connect, share ideas, or even swap success stories.
Your input keeps this newsletter fresh and valuable. Let’s start a conversation—email me, DM me, or comment anytime. Can’t wait to hear from you!
— Mark
www.marklevy.co
Follow me on Linkedin
Thanks for being here. I’ll see you next Tuesday at 8:15 am ET.
👉I If you enjoyed this newsletter and value this work, please consider forwarding it to your friends and colleagues or sharing it on social media. New to DCX? Sign Up.
✉️ Join 1,370+ CX Leaders Who Get the DCX Newsletter First
Human-centered insights. Plug-and-play frameworks. Smart tools that actually work.
All designed for CX pros who want to build with purpose—and deliver with impact.
👉 Subscribe today and get the tools to elevate your strategy (and your sanity).