DCX #114 | Is Your Business Exhausting Your Customers?
Less is More: The Surprising Link Between Fewer Choices and Superior CX
Weekly inspiration, education, and coaching for customer-obsessed leaders.
The DCX Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. Please consider joining the community as a paid subscriber to support the continued creation of posts like this.
Welcome to the DCX Newsletter
Here's a sneak peek of what's in store:
Pick One
Streamlining Choices: A How-To Guide
Architecting a Better Decision Environment
The Future of Choice
Ready? Let’s go!
The "30 Days to Greater Influence" e-course isn't for everyone.
It's for the Customer Experience professional who:
Knows they're capable of more but feel stuck in their current role
Wants to drive real change in their organization
Is ready to invest 10 minutes a day in their professional growth
My Promise to You:
At the end of 30 days, you will have the tools to make your voice heard, your ideas implemented, and your impact felt throughout your organization.
I’m so confident in the value of this course that I’m offering it at no cost. Your only investment is your time and commitment.
P.S. "The person who stops learning, stops doing." - Howard Gardner, Harvard psychologist.
Don't let that person be you.
Pick One
Imagine this: You're standing in the cereal aisle, facing a kaleidoscope of colorful boxes. Fruity, chocolatey, healthy, indulgent – it's all there. You came for a quick breakfast fix, but now you're frozen, overwhelmed by options. Sound familiar?
Welcome to the modern consumer's dilemma – where abundance can lead to decision gridlock.
This scene plays out countless times daily, not just in supermarkets but in every corner of our lives.
We're inundated with choices, from the myriad shades of white paint at the hardware store (who knew "eggshell" and "ivory" were mortal enemies?) to the endless scroll of movies on streaming platforms.
But here's some food for thought: What if fewer choices could actually enhance your customers' experience?
As customer experience professionals, we often fall into the "more is more" trap.
Surely, if we offer every possible option, everyone will find their perfect match, right? Well, not quite. We might be serving up a buffet of confusion with a side of anxiety.
This phenomenon is known as the paradox of choice.
It's more devious than that friend who always says "I'm fine with anything" when choosing where to eat.
This paradox masquerades as freedom and abundance but often leads to anxiety, selection gridlock, and buyer's remorse. And it's affecting your customers more than you might realize.
The Great Jam Experiment
To understand this better, let's look at a fascinating study. In 2000, psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper conducted what's now known as the "jam experiment."
On some days, they offered shoppers 24 varieties of jam. On others, just 6.
The results? While the large display attracted more browsers, only 3% made a purchase. With the smaller display? A whopping 30% bought jam.
Who knew less jam could lead to more... well, jam sales?
This wasn't just about preserves. Iyengar and Lepper's work sparked a wave of research into option abundance. They found similar patterns with everything from 401(k) plans to chocolates. More options often led to choice-induced hesitation and lower satisfaction.
The Upside of Downsizing
When we thoughtfully reduce options, we're not just simplifying our offerings—we're enhancing our customers' experience in several ways:
Reduced Cognitive Load: Every decision requires mental energy. Fewer options mean less mental fatigue for our customers.
Increased Confidence: With a more manageable set of choices, customers are less likely to second-guess their decisions.
Speedier Decision-Making: Less time spent choosing means more time for customers to enjoy their purchase or experience.
Higher Satisfaction: When customers have fewer options to compare against, they're often more content with their final choice.
Improved Operational Efficiency: As we'll see in our real-world examples, fewer options can lead to smoother operations.
Potential for Higher Sales: Sometimes, a streamlined selection can actually boost your bottom line.
By focusing on these benefits, we can create a win-win situation: happier customers and a more efficient business.
Real-World Success Stories
Let's look at some companies that took the leap and actually reduced choices. The results might surprise you.
Procter & Gamble's Massive Simplification Effort
Almost 10 years ago, P&G underwent a dramatic change, reducing the size of its product portfolio from 225 brands to 65. It scaled back its presence in 22 product categories to just 10. “We focused on categories that were daily use,” P&G’s CEO Moeller said. “We returned to the core, to the things that we're really good at.” The result was a growth in market capitalization from about $150 billion in 2009 to about $350 billion today.
The Cheesecake Factory's Pandemic Menu
Known for a menu thicker than some novels, The Cheesecake Factory was forced to adapt during the COVID-19 pandemic. They created a limited menu with about 125 items (still more than most restaurants, but hey, baby steps). This streamlined menu led to improved operational efficiency and higher guest satisfaction scores.
Apple's Product Line Strategy
When Steve Jobs returned to Apple in 1997, he famously reduced the company's product line by 70%. This drastic simplification helped turn the company around. Jobs said, "Deciding what not to do is as important as deciding what to do." This strategy of offering fewer, but highly refined products has become Apple's calling card.
These examples show that reducing choice can lead to real benefits in customer satisfaction, efficiency, and profits.
Streamlining Choices: A How-To Guide
So, you're convinced that less can be more. But how do you put this into practice without leaving your customers feeling short-changed? Here are some strategies to help you navigate the delicate balance between choice and chaos:
1. Conduct a Choice Audit
First things first: take stock of your current offerings. Are all those options really necessary? Here's a quick exercise:
List all your products or services
For each, ask: "If we didn't offer this, would anyone really miss it?"
Look at sales data: Which options are your top performers? Which are the stragglers?
Remember, you're not looking to slash your offerings to the bone, just trim the fat. Think of it as Marie Kondo-ing your product line – if it doesn't spark joy (or sales), thank it for its service and let it go.
2. Categorize and Conquer
Sometimes, the problem isn't the number of choices, but how they're presented. Try these tactics:
Group similar options together
Use clear, descriptive categories
Highlight recommended or popular choices
Take a cue from Netflix. They don't reduce their vast library; they make it manageable through smart categorization and personalized recommendations.
3. The Power of Defaults
Here's a secret weapon in choice architecture: the humble default option. By pre-selecting a "standard" choice, you can:
Reduce decision fatigue for customers
Guide them towards options you know work well
Still offer alternatives for those who want them
Think about how your phone came with pre-installed apps. You didn't choose them, but they were there when you needed them. (And let's be honest, how many of us have actually changed our ringtone from the default?)
4. The Goldilocks Principle: Not Too Much, Not Too Little
Remember the story of Goldilocks? She wasn't looking for the biggest bowl of porridge or the smallest – she wanted the one that was just right. Your customers are the same.
The ideal number of choices varies by industry and context, but research suggests that somewhere between 3-7 options often hits the sweet spot. It's enough to feel like a choice, without being overwhelming.
For example, when Apple revolutionized the MP3 player market with the iPod, they didn't offer 20 different models. They had small, medium, and large capacity options. Simple, but effective.
5. Tell a Story, Not a Spec Sheet
Instead of bombarding customers with every possible feature and option, focus on the benefits and experiences your products provide.
For instance, don't just list a camera's technical specs. Paint a picture: "Capture your baby's first steps in crystal-clear slow motion," or "Never miss a shot, even in low light."
By shifting from features to benefits, you help customers imagine how your product fits into their lives, making the choice more meaningful and less about comparing endless specifications.
6. Test, Learn, and Adapt
Implementing these strategies isn't a one-and-done deal. It's an ongoing process of refinement. Here's how to approach it:
Start small: Choose one product line or service area to experiment with
A/B test: Try different choice architectures and see what resonates
Gather feedback: Actually talk to your customers about their experience
Iterate: Use what you learn to continuously improve
Remember, Amazon didn't perfect its "Customers who bought this also bought..." feature overnight. It evolved through constant testing and refinement.
Five More Strategies to Streamline Your Offerings
The "Desert Island" Approach
Imagine your customers are stranded on a desert island. What five products or services would they absolutely need to survive? This thought experiment forces you to focus on your core offerings. Anything that doesn't make the cut might be ripe for elimination or consolidation.
The "Grandma Test"
Can your grandmother understand your product lineup? If not, it might be too complicated. Walk through your offerings with someone unfamiliar with your industry. Their confusion points are likely your customers' pain points too.
The "80/20 Rule"
Audit Look at your sales data. Chances are, 80% of your revenue comes from 20% of your products. Consider trimming the bottom 20% that contribute little to your bottom line. They might be creating more confusion than value.
The "One In, One Out"
Policy For every new product or feature you add, commit to removing an old one. This keeps your lineup fresh without bloating your offerings. It forces you to constantly evaluate the value of each item.
The "Customer Journey Map" Cleanup
Map out your typical customer's journey. At each touchpoint, ask: "Does having multiple options here help or hinder the customer?" If it's slowing them down or causing confusion, that's a prime spot to simplify.
Remember, the goal isn't to slash options arbitrarily. It's about curating a lineup that makes your customers' lives easier. Sometimes, that means offering fewer, but better, choices. These strategies can help you find that sweet spot where simplicity meets satisfaction.
Architecting a Better Decision Environment
Ever walked into a store and found yourself inexplicably drawn to a particular product? Or noticed how some websites seem to guide you effortlessly towards a purchase? That's not accidental – it's choice architecture in action, and it's about to become your new best friend in the quest for customer satisfaction.
Choice architecture is the art and science of how choices are presented to consumers. It's like being the interior designer of decision-making – you're not changing the choices themselves, but you're arranging them in a way that makes the whole experience more pleasant and effective. For example:
Dynamic choice sets that adapt in real-time based on user behavior
Gamified decision-making processes that make choosing fun rather than stressful
Collaborative filtering systems that leverage the wisdom of the crowd to help guide individual choices
Here are a few blueprints to get you started:
The Power of Defaults: People tend to stick with pre-set options, so choose your defaults wisely.
The Decoy Effect: Introduce a slightly less attractive option to make your preferred option look even better.
Chunking: Break down complex decisions into smaller, manageable chunks.
The Power of Now: Frame benefits in terms of immediate gains to encourage particular choices.
Social Proof: Show what other customers have chosen to influence decisions.
Remember, the goal of choice architecture isn't to manipulate, but to facilitate. You're not trying to force customers into decisions they don't want to make. Instead, you're creating an environment where making a good choice feels as natural and painless as possible.
Rocking the Boat: Overcoming Resistance to Change
Of course, reducing choice isn't without its challenges. You might face resistance from product teams who've invested time and resources into developing various options. There might be concerns about losing market share or alienating niche customer segments. And there's always the challenge of balancing simplification with personalization.
To address these concerns, it's crucial to measure the impact of your changes. Key metrics to track include:
Conversion rates: Are more customers completing purchases?
Customer satisfaction scores: How do customers feel about their experience?
Time-to-decision: How long does it take customers to make a choice?
Average order value: Are customers spending more?
A/B testing can be particularly valuable here. Try offering a simplified set of choices to one group of customers and your full range to another. Compare the results to see which approach performs better.
AI and machine learning may offer ways to provide personalized, limited choices to each customer based on their preferences and behavior. This could allow us to reap the benefits of reduced choice while still catering to individual needs.
Wrapping Up: The Art of Less
In a world that often equates more with better, embracing the power of less can feel counterintuitive. But as we've seen, thoughtfully reducing choice can lead to happier customers, streamlined operations, and even increased sales.
Remember, the goal isn't to limit your customers' options, but to present choices in a way that enhances rather than overwhelms their experience. It's about curating, not cutting.
So, the next time you're tempted to add just one more option to your product line or feature list, pause and ask yourself: "Am I adding value, or just noise?"
Now, over to you:
How can you start simplifying choices for your customers today?
The power is in your hands – and with these strategies, you're well-equipped to make impactful changes that your customers will appreciate.
🌟 Exclusive Content for Paid Subscribers🌟
Become a paid subscriber, and you'll receive an exclusive, carefully curated roundup of the latest industry news, groundbreaking ideas, insightful links, and top recommendations every Sunday morning + so much more.
Stay ahead of the curve with DCX Links and make informed decisions that drive your success.
Here’s the latest one to get a flavor of the content and value.
The Future of Choice
As we peer into the future, the landscape of choice is set to evolve dramatically. Here's a deeper look at what's on the horizon:
AI-Powered Personalization
Artificial Intelligence is reshaping how we present choices to customers. Instead of a one-size-fits-all approach, AI algorithms will analyze vast amounts of data to offer personalized, curated selections for each customer. Imagine walking into a store and seeing only the products that match your style, size, and budget. Online retailers like Amazon are already using AI to refine recommendations, but this technology will become more sophisticated and widespread.
Predictive Choice Architecture
Advanced analytics will allow companies to predict what customers want before they even know they want it. This could lead to 'smart defaults' where the most likely choice is pre-selected, reducing decision fatigue. For example, a coffee shop app might automatically suggest your usual order but with a seasonal twist based on your past preferences.
Voice and Natural Language Processing
As voice-activated assistants become more prevalent, the way we present choices will adapt. Instead of scrolling through options, customers might engage in a conversation to narrow down their choices. This could make complex decisions feel more natural and less overwhelming.
Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality (VR)
These technologies will revolutionize how we experience choices. Imagine trying on clothes virtually or seeing how furniture looks in your home before buying. This immersive experience could actually increase the number of options we can comfortably consider by making the selection process more engaging and less abstract.
Blockchain and Transparency
As customers become more conscious about the origins and impact of their purchases, blockchain technology could provide unprecedented transparency. This might lead to a new dimension of choice, where customers can easily see the entire supply chain and make decisions based on ethical considerations.
Subscription and Curation Services
The rise of subscription boxes and curated services suggests a future where customers increasingly outsource choice. Instead of choosing individual products, they might opt for expert-curated selections, trusting brands to make good choices on their behalf.
Neuromarketing and Choice
Advances in neuroscience will give us deeper insights into how the brain makes decisions. This could lead to more scientifically designed choice architectures that balance options with cognitive load.
Regulatory Influences
As the impact of choice overload becomes more recognized, we might see regulations around how choices are presented, especially in critical areas like healthcare or financial services. This could lead to standardized ways of presenting options to protect consumer interests.
Emotional AI
Future AI might be able to read emotional cues to understand when a customer is feeling overwhelmed by choices. It could then adapt in real-time, perhaps simplifying options or offering decision support.
Gamification of Choice
To make the selection process more engaging, companies might gamify the experience of choosing. This could turn potentially overwhelming decisions into fun, interactive experiences that guide customers to their best options.
As CX professionals, staying ahead of these trends will be crucial. The future isn't about offering more choices, but about offering smarter, more meaningful choices. By leveraging these emerging technologies and insights, we can create experiences that are not just personalized, but truly empowering for our customers.
Did I miss anything?
Thanks for being here. I’ll see you next Tuesday at 8:15 am ET.
Until then, please reach out 👋
I started this newsletter to help customer-obsessed professionals deliver better customer experiences — and to have more conversations with friendly and interesting people exactly like you! 😊
If you ever...
have feedback for me
have a question or a problem around customer experience/strategy/team building or more
want to say hello
...then please get in touch. I'd love to hear from you!
— Mark
www.marklevy.co
P.S.: 👉 If you enjoyed this newsletter and value this work, please consider forwarding it to your friends and colleagues or sharing on social media. New to DCX? Sign Up.
One More Thing:
I want to share some of the exciting content and programs that I have created for your personal and professional growth:
30 Days to Greater Influence – a FREE email course crafted specifically for customer-obsessed leaders like us.
DCX Executive Coaching - 1:1 coaching for customer-obsessed leaders (Mention DCX for 50% off the first three months)
The Daily Challenge SMS Service - Daily text messages designed to uplift your spirit, remind you of your worth, and inspire you to keep going, no matter what. - 7-Day FREE Trial
365 Days of Accountability - Accountability Books, Journals, and Exercises
I hope you find these programs useful. Let me know if you have any questions or need any further assistance.