7 Psychological Hacks to Boost CX and Build Loyalty
Discover how a few psychological principles can turn ordinary customer interactions into loyalty-building magic.
Weekly inspiration, education, and coaching for customer-obsessed leaders.
Thank you!
A huge shoutout to my Premium subscribers, who generously support the DCX Newsletter. I’m humbled that many are expensing it through their companies as a valuable educational resource. If you want to do the same, this email template gives your manager all the info you’ll need.
—Welcome to the DCX Newsletter—
In 1966, two psychologists, Freedman and Fraser, discovered that if you could get someone to agree to a small, almost trivial request, they’d be much more likely to say yes to a bigger favor later on.
It’s called the “foot-in-the-door” technique, and it’s one of the most interesting tricks our brains play on us.
It’s about consistency—we love to see ourselves as consistent, and when we agree once, we want to keep agreeing to stay that way.
What does this have to do with customer experience?
A lot more than you’d think.
Great CX isn’t just about making things easier or smoother.
It’s about tapping into what makes customers tick and using psychology to make their experience so good that they keep coming back.
And that’s where sales psychology comes in.
It’s not just for sales folks—it's a secret weapon for us in CX too.
Ever wonder how the psychology of buying can level up your customer experience game?
Let’s dive in and figure out how to use these insights to make every customer interaction more powerful and personal.
The Tale of the Almost-Lost Customer
Here’s a story for you.
A customer calls in, ready to cancel their subscription.
They're frustrated and feel like they’re not getting what they paid for.
Most reps would rush to a generic save offer to avoid the cancellation, but not this one.
Instead, they listen closely, acknowledge the frustration, and then—after fully understanding the situation—they offer an unexpected, personalized incentive: a discount for staying and some extra features to sweeten the deal.
No hard sell, no pressure—just empathy and a sprinkle of reciprocity.
And guess what?
The customer stays.
That’s what I mean by blending empathy with sales psychology to turn things around.
Persuasion + Empathy = The Winning Combo
Persuasion isn’t manipulation.
It’s about understanding what motivates people—why they do what they do—and using that insight to help them better.
Let’s break down a few of these psychological principles and see how they can power up CX:
1. Reciprocity: Give a Little, Get a Lot
Robert Cialdini taught us about reciprocity (Cialdini, 2006)—when you give something, people want to give back.
In CX, this means offering small, unexpected rewards.
It could be loyalty points, a discount, or just extra effort in solving a problem.
You’re making customers feel valued, and that’s huge.
2. Loss Aversion: Fear of Missing Out
People hate losing out more than they love gaining something (Kahneman & Tversky, 1979).
So, if a customer’s hesitating to upgrade, give them a gentle nudge about what they’re missing out on.
You’re not being pushy—you’re helping them see the full picture.
3. Social Proof: Follow the Crowd
Humans trust what others are doing.
Reviews, testimonials, success stories—these are gold in CX (Cialdini, 2001).
Airbnb does this so well.
When a customer’s unsure, seeing how others found value can tip the scales.
Amazon uses this, too—highlighting frequently bought-together items.
It's about showing that others trust your product or service, so they can too.
4. Scarcity: Act Now, But Mean It
Scarcity is powerful, but only when it’s real.
A limited-time offer or a few spots left can create urgency, but it has to be honest (Lynn, 1991).
Fake scarcity?
That’s a trust killer.
Genuine urgency, though?
That’s how you get people to take action while still feeling good about it.
5. Anchoring: Set the Reference
Anchoring is all about giving a reference point (Tversky & Kahneman, 1974).
If you start by presenting a higher-priced plan, the lower-priced one suddenly looks like a great deal.
It works with setting expectations, too—give a longer timeline to solve an issue, then beat it.
That’s how you delight customers.
6. Emotional Framing: Feel Before You Fix
We know our customers’ pain points.
The trick is to frame our messages to connect with those feelings.
Deloitte found that emotionally engaged customers are more likely to recommend a brand (Deloitte, 2019).
If someone’s frustrated, start by acknowledging it before diving into solutions.
It’s not just about fixing the problem—it’s about seeing their struggle.
7 Foot-in-the-Door: Start Small, Grow Big
This one’s a classic—start with a small ask, and it often leads to more (Freedman & Fraser, 1966).
If a customer reaches out with a simple question, don’t stop there.
Once they’ve taken that first small action, they’re more likely to keep going. It’s all about building momentum.
Make It Stick: Using Psychology Every Day
You don’t need a psychology degree to use these insights. Here are some easy ways to get started:
Frame it with empathy: Next time you’ve got an escalation, connect emotionally before diving in.
Show what others are doing: Use testimonials or success stories during onboarding to build confidence.
Reward them: Offer small incentives—a discount, loyalty points—something that says, “We appreciate you.”
The key is balance.
Use these techniques ethically.
Make customers feel respected and supported.
CX and sales psychology aren’t separate worlds—they’re deeply connected.
If you use these ideas, you’ll help customers make better decisions and give them experiences worth remembering.
Next time you’re interacting with a customer, pull a page from the psychology playbook.
Your customers will feel it—and so will your bottom line.
The Key Takeaways
Reciprocity: Give something unexpected to make customers feel valued.
Loss Aversion: Remind customers what they stand to lose, not just gain.
Social Proof: Use testimonials and success stories to build trust.
Scarcity: Create urgency, but be honest about it.
Anchoring: Set expectations so that choices seem clear and attractive.
Emotional Framing: Acknowledge emotions to pave the way for real connection.
Foot-in-the-Door: Guide customers with small asks to lead to bigger engagement.
Ready to level up your CX game?
Join the DCX community as a Premium subscriber and help fuel more in-depth, actionable content like this. Plus, get exclusive access to insights and strategies you won’t want to miss!
NEW: A CX Leader’s Guide to Organizational Buy-in
Quickly create a customer-centric culture across your entire organization.
🌟 Exclusive Content for Premium Subscribers🌟
Become a Premium subscriber, and you'll receive an exclusive, carefully curated roundup of the latest industry news, groundbreaking ideas, insightful links, and top recommendations every Sunday morning + so much more.
Stay ahead of the curve with DCX Links and make informed decisions that drive your success.
Here are recent editions to help you get a flavor of the content and value:
👋 Please Reach Out
I started this newsletter to help customer-obsessed professionals deliver better customer experiences — and to have more conversations with friendly and interesting people exactly like you! 😊 If you ever...
have feedback for me
have a question or a problem around customer experience/strategy/team building or more
want to say hello
...then please get in touch. I'd love to hear from you!
— Mark
www.marklevy.co
Follow me on Linkedin
Are you looking to get in front of 1K+ Customer-obsessed Leaders? Sponsor The DCX Newsletter
Thanks for being here. I’ll see you next Tuesday at 8:15 am ET.
👉 If you enjoyed this newsletter and value this work, please consider forwarding it to your friends and colleagues or sharing it on social media. New to DCX? Sign Up.
PS.
I want to share some of the exciting content and programs that I have created for your personal and professional growth:
Transform Your Influence, Transform Your Future
30 Days to Greater Influence is an email course that will help you become the go-to expert your colleagues rely on for critical decisions, get executives to champion your customer-centric initiatives, and leave work each day knowing you’ve made a real, tangible difference for your customers. And more!
SPECIAL FOR DCX READERS: For a limited time, get the best-selling CX course for 70% off.
DCX Executive Coaching - 1:1 coaching for customer-obsessed leaders (Mention DCX for 50% off the first three months)
The Daily Challenge SMS Service - Daily text messages designed to uplift your spirit, remind you of your worth, and inspire you to keep going, no matter what. - 7-Day FREE Trial
365 Days of Accountability - Accountability Books, Journals, and Exercises
I hope you find these programs useful. Let me know if you have any questions or need any further assistance.
Love this! You set a high bar for all of us on Substack!
Love this…
“No hard sell, no pressure—just empathy and a sprinkle of reciprocity.”