The Case of the Silent Cancellation
A detective story about spotting the warning signs before it's too late
Weekly inspiration, education, and coaching for customer-obsessed leaders.
Thank you!
A huge shoutout to my Premium subscribers, who generously support the DCX Newsletter. I’m humbled that many are expensing it through their companies as a valuable educational resource. If you want to do the same, this email template gives your manager all the info you’ll need. Either way, get started with a 7-day Free trial.
—Welcome to the DCX Newsletter—
You're staring at your screen at 10 PM, and something feels off: "FEEDBACK: 10/10 - EXPERIENCE RATING: PERFECT."
Should you be celebrating?
Sure, perfect feedback is supposed to be the dream.
But if you've been in the customer experience game long enough, you know that knot in your stomach when things look too perfect.
And here's the thing - you're not just being paranoid.
A few years back, some researchers at Columbia and London Business School actually proved that those perfect-score customers are often the ones quietly planning their exit.
The office is empty at this hour - just you and the gentle hum of the HVAC.
Perfect thinking conditions for what you're about to do.
You pull up your behavioral analysis dashboard - a tool you built during similarly late nights after one too many "perfect" customers disappeared without warning.
Over years of late-night data diving, you've learned to spot three distinct patterns.
Like a detective's guide to the customer psyche, these patterns have never failed you.
And the fascinating part? Research actually backs up what your instincts have been telling you.
The Too-Perfect Suspect: Case #2847
Tonight's mystery centers on Sarah Chen, premium member of your wellness platform for two years.
On paper, she's showing all the classic signs of what the researchers call the "At Risk" state - that deceptively perfect pattern that keeps you up at night.
You've seen this pattern enough times to recognize the tells:
Clockwork-like engagement: opening every email within hours of receiving it
High volume, low depth: completing meditation sessions but never exploring beyond the basics
Surface-level perfection: hitting every metric but never creating personal routines
Systematic behavior: following every prompt but rarely joining discussions
Feedback flatline: no complaints, no suggestions, no emotional investment
The research confirms your suspicions - these methodical, "perfect" users often interact more with your product right before they leave, almost like they're doing one final audit before making their decision.
The Real Deal
You glance at the other active profiles on your dashboard.
There's James, a living example of the "Engaged" state.
His pattern tells a completely different story:
Organic engagement: irregular usage times but consistent weekly commitment
Deep exploration: tries new features without prompting
Community catalyst: initiates discussions, shares experiences
Creative adaptation: customizes meditation sequences to his needs
Constructive feedback: offers specific suggestions for improvement
Growth trajectory: started as a basic user, now leading group sessions
The research validates what you've observed - these customers who evolve from users to creators show 45% higher retention rates.
They're not perfect, but they're perfectly invested in growing with your platform.
Cold Case Chronicles
Then your eyes drift to that third category on your dashboard - the "Silently Gone" state.
Like Maria from last quarter. The pattern is distinctive in its fade-out:
Early warning signs: engagement drops within first few weeks
Passive consumption: opens emails but zero clicks
No customization: never personalizes settings or preferences
Community silence: never engages with other users
Ghost pattern: activity decreases so gradually it's easy to miss
Zero response: no reaction to new features or promotions
The researchers found what you've long suspected - these patterns develop early, often in the first few weeks.
Once they set in, they're like ghosts in your system, haunting your engagement metrics with their technically-active but essentially-dormant presence.
Looking back at Sarah's data with fresh eyes, you spot something interesting.
She's following the "At Risk" pattern, but there's a twist.
While her meditation session completion is perfect, you notice micro-variations in her practice times.
Unlike your typical "At Risk" user who sticks to the same time slot, Sarah's varying by up to an hour.
It's a tiny detail, but it suggests she might still be personally invested enough to adapt the practice to her real life - a potential opening for intervention.
The patterns crystallize more clearly now:
Three straight months of perfect scores (a classic "At Risk" warning sign)
High activity but decreasing community involvement (the transition zone)
Opens everything you send but engagement is dropping
Zero complaints (your biggest red flag)
But those varying practice times... a glimmer of hope?
You've seen this movie before.
Without intervention, Sarah's heading down one of two paths: she'll either join the ranks of the "Silently Gone," slipping away without a word, or she'll suddenly unsubscribe, another "perfect" customer gone.
Staying on top of the latest CX trends is tough, especially with how AI is transforming the field. Thankfully, the DCX newsletter does a brilliant job of curating the must-know info.” - Jimmy, CX Leader, Google
Breaking Protocol: The 3 AM Gambit
But tonight, you're going to try something different.
At 3 AM, you draft an email that might make traditional CX folks cringe:
"Sarah - Your meditation mastery is seriously impressive. Want to help us design what's next?"
Why?
Because you've seen the research showing that transforming customers from users to creators boosts retention by 45%.
You're not just giving her another feature to play with - you're trying to shift her from that dangerous "At Risk" state to the stable "Engaged" state.
By morning, Sarah's not only accepted - she's already designed three custom meditation sequences.
But more importantly, her pattern is shifting.
She's moving toward the more sustainable "Engaged" state, where customers don't just use your product - they help shape it.
Case Files: Lessons from the Late Shift
You close your case file for the night, pulling out your worn leather notebook - the one that's seen too many perfect customers disappear.
Tonight's case has reinforced some old truths and revealed some new ones:
1. The Perfect Customer Paradox
Perfect patterns are often warning signs.
Like a too-clean crime scene, they're usually hiding something.
Research shows customers giving perfect scores are 23% more likely to churn within six months.
Look for the story behind the spotless metrics - it's usually where the real clues lie.
2. The Engagement Evolution Theory
Your best customers aren't the ones who never have problems - they're the ones who help solve them.
James and his fellow "Engaged" state users prove it: customers who become creators show 45% higher retention rates.
They're not staying for your product alone; they're staying because they've become part of your product's story.
3. The Silent Departure Doctrine
By the time you spot a silent churner, they're usually long gone mentally.
The research is clear: these patterns set in during the first few weeks.
Your best chance?
Early intervention and pattern recognition. Don't wait for the silence to become deafening.
4. The Creation Connection
Sarah's transformation proves what research has been telling us - the path from "At Risk" to "Engaged" runs through creation, not consumption.
Give your perfect customers a chance to be imperfect creators, and they might just stick around to perfect their creations instead.
5. The 3 AM Insight
Sometimes the best solutions break the playbook.
Traditional CX wisdom says to celebrate perfect scores.
Your late-night detective work (and the research) suggests otherwise: look for ways to disrupt the perfection before it becomes a pattern.
Case closed.
Now, it’s time to scan your dashboard for users showing those "too perfect" patterns.
After all, in customer experience, the best detectives know that sometimes the most promising clues are hidden in plain sight - in those suspiciously perfect engagement metrics.
Want the science behind your late-night detective work?
Check out "Some Customers Would Rather Leave Without Saying Goodbye" by Ascarza, Netzer & Hardie. They proved what your CX instincts have been telling you - sometimes, your most active customers are actually packing their bags.
Ready to level up your CX game?
Join the DCX community as a Premium subscriber and help fuel more in-depth, actionable content like this. Plus, get exclusive access to insights and strategies you won’t want to miss!
NEW: A CX Leader’s Guide to Organizational Buy-in
Quickly create a customer-centric culture across your entire organization.
🌟 Exclusive Content for Premium Subscribers🌟
Become a Premium subscriber, and you'll receive an exclusive, carefully curated roundup of the latest industry news, groundbreaking ideas, insightful links, and top recommendations every Sunday morning + so much more.
Stay ahead of the curve with DCX Links and make informed decisions that drive your success.
Here are recent editions to help you get a flavor of the content and value:
👋 Please Reach Out
I started this newsletter to help customer-obsessed professionals deliver better customer experiences — and to have more conversations with friendly and interesting people exactly like you! 😊 If you ever...
have feedback for me
have a question or a problem around customer experience/strategy/team building or more
want to say hello
...then please get in touch. I'd love to hear from you!
— Mark
www.marklevy.co
Follow me on Linkedin
Are you looking to get in front of 1K+ Customer-obsessed Leaders? Sponsor The DCX Newsletter
Thanks for being here. I’ll see you next Tuesday at 8:15 am ET.
👉 If you enjoyed this newsletter and value this work, please consider forwarding it to your friends and colleagues or sharing it on social media. New to DCX? Sign Up.
PS.
I want to share some of the exciting content and programs that I have created for your personal and professional growth:
Transform Your Influence, Transform Your Future
30 Days to Greater Influence is an email course that will help you become the go-to expert your colleagues rely on for critical decisions, get executives to champion your customer-centric initiatives, and leave work each day knowing you’ve made a real, tangible difference for your customers. And more!
SPECIAL FOR DCX READERS: For a limited time, get the best-selling CX course for 70% off.
DCX Executive Coaching
1:1 coaching for customer-obsessed leaders (Mention DCX for 50% off the first three months)
The Daily Challenge SMS Service
Daily text messages designed to uplift your spirit, remind you of your worth, and inspire you to keep going, no matter what. - 7-Day FREE Trial
365 Days of Accountability
Accountability Books, Journals, and Exercises
I hope you find these programs useful. Let me know if you have any questions or need any further assistance.
DCX is so comprehensive. Nice work.
Appreciate this perspective/insight, Mark!
“research showing that transforming customers from users to creators boosts retention by 45%.”
Creating a sense of belonging by allowing others to be a part of the evolution/creation of our product/service. TY